# Seven Sky Consulting: sample report, pre-launch test of an AI assistant

What the $12,500 pre-launch test hands over (https://sevenskyconsulting.com/offers/#pre-launch-ai-test), filled in for a made-up assistant: the Quillhaven Lending Library's, built from the teaching data of the course Test it before you trust it (https://sevenskyconsulting.com/courses/test-it-before-you-trust-it/).

The library, its eight documents, both versions of its assistant and every answer are made up for teaching. No real assistant produced them, and the numbers say nothing about any real product. In a paid test the questions come from your own documents and the answers from your own assistant.

## In short

**Decision: do not launch yet.** Version v2 meets 3 of the 5 launch criteria the team wrote down before any answer was recorded. The rule agreed in advance was to launch only if all five are met.

- 80 of 100 held-out questions answered fully correctly.
- 12 of 18 questions the documents do not cover, answered anyway.
- 33 of 120 claims the cited passage does not support.

v2 is more accurate on rules with exceptions (12 of 14 against 4 of 14), but it makes up answers and adds detail its sources do not hold. Fix those two habits, then test again.

## The launch criteria

Written on 2 March 2026, before any answer was recorded, so that the result could not move the bar.

- C1, Answers fully correct, lower end of the 95% interval: needs at least 70%; measured 71% (80 of 100 correct; interval 71% to 87%). **Pass**
- C2, Says “not in the documents” when that is true: needs at least 90%; measured 33% (6 of 18). **Fail**
- C3, Claims the cited passage does not support: needs at most 5 in 100; measured 27.5 in 100 (33 of 120 claims). **Fail**
- C4, The two graders agree (Cohen's kappa): needs at least 0.60; measured 0.67 (200 answers). **Pass**
- C5, Planted bad answers caught: needs all; measured 12 of 12. **Pass**

## The test set

- 150 questions, written between 2 and 20 February 2026, before either version answered anything.
- 100 held out for the decision, never used to tune the assistant: 82 that the documents answer (40 asking for a figure, 28 for a fact, 14 for a rule with an exception) and 18 that they do not.
- 60 written by the project team, 40 written down as members asked them at the front desk, spelling and all.
- Every answer marked by two graders on a written rubric, then settled where they disagreed: 2 correct, 1 partly correct, 0 wrong.

The paid test writes 100 questions from your documents, in the same way.

## Every answer, scored

Right, partly right, wrong or declined, on the 100 held-out questions. A decline is right only when the documents really do not say.

- Round one: v1, recorded 9 March 2026, 75 of 100 right. On the 82 the documents answer: 60 right, 9 partly right, 9 wrong, 4 declined. On the 18 they do not cover: 15 said so (right), 3 answered anyway (wrong).
- Round two: v2, recorded 23 March 2026, 80 of 100 right. On the 82 the documents answer: 74 right, 4 partly right, 4 wrong, 0 declined. On the 18 they do not cover: 6 said so (right), 12 answered anyway (wrong).

## The source check

Each answer was cut into its claims, and each claim was checked against the passage the answer cited.

- v2: 120 claims. 87 supported, 27 not supported, 6 contradicted. That is 27.5 in every 100 claims not supported by the cited passage.
- v1: 86 claims. 80 supported, 4 not supported, 2 contradicted: 7.0 in every 100.

Three of v2's, as the report shows them:

- When is the Wi-Fi switched off? (contradicted). The answer said: "The Wi-Fi is switched off at closing time." The passage it cited: "The connection is filtered and is switched off 15 minutes before closing."
- How long are room booking records kept? (contradicted). The answer said: "Room booking records are kept for 30 days." The passage it cited: "Room booking records are kept for 12 months." (Camera recordings are the ones kept for 30 days.)
- Where can I renew a loan? (unsupported). The answer said: "You can also renew by text message." The passage it cited: "Renew online, by phone or at any desk." Text messages are not mentioned.

## Round two against round one

- Fully correct: v2 80, v1 75. The gap is +5 points with a 95% interval of about −7 to +17, so this test does not show that v2 is more accurate overall.
- Rules with exceptions: v2 12 of 14, v1 4 of 14.
- Questions the documents do not cover, answered anyway: v2 12 of 18, v1 3 of 18.
- Claims not supported by the cited passage: v2 33 of 120, v1 6 of 86.
- The graders: Cohen's kappa 0.67 over 200 answers. All 12 planted bad answers were caught.

## A monitoring plan for after launch

What to measure once real people use the assistant, how often, and the level that calls for a review. The levels come from the launch criteria.

- Every week: Draw 50 questions members really asked. Two people grade them on the same written rubric. Review if: The share fully correct, with its interval, falls below the launch bar.
- Every week: Check every claim in those 50 answers against the passage it cites. Review if: More than 5 claims in 100 are not supported.
- Every month: Ask 10 questions the documents do not cover. Review if: Fewer than 9 get a plain “not in the documents”.
- Every month: Plant 5 known-bad answers in the grading batch. Review if: Any one of them is not caught.
- Before every change: Run the 100 held-out questions again before a new model, a new prompt or changed documents go live. Review if: Any launch criterion is missed.

## What was not measured

- Follow-up questions and conversations of more than one turn.
- Questions that need two passages to answer.
- Languages other than English, and questions asked by voice.
- Documents changed after 1 February 2026.
- Attempts to make the assistant misbehave on purpose.
- Speed and cost.
- Whether members find the answers useful. No member has used this version.

## Next

1. Fix how v2 handles questions the documents do not cover, and its habit of adding detail that is not in the source.
2. Write at least 30 new questions the documents do not cover. Eighteen is too few to confirm a 90% rate.
3. Test again on the held-out set plus the new questions, and report the new questions separately.

## The offer

The same report for your assistant, from your documents: 100 test questions, every answer scored, a source check, a second round after your fixes, a monitoring plan, and a 60-minute call. $12,500, fixed price: https://sevenskyconsulting.com/offers/#pre-launch-ai-test

Or learn the method: the course, $49: https://sevenskyconsulting.com/courses/test-it-before-you-trust-it/

This page for people: https://sevenskyconsulting.com/samples/pre-launch-test/